In one sense Job has taken a tremendous stand, but he has spoken unworthily and doubted God’s goodness to him. The Lord therefore begins to rebuke him.
Who is this who darkens counsel by interpreting God’s trials and providence with such ignorance? Better to say that we do not understand than to assume that we do understand and put a false interpretation on events. The one who has not yet understood leaves open the possibility of a true explanation, but to reach a false conclusion is to seal our own ignorance. Calvin remarks that we learn that when the whole world has joined forces together to oppose God, it all amounts to nothing. God can afford to invite his enemies with their best weapons and to face him and battle and they will be utterly routed.
This is addressed to Job as the previous verse has made clear and not, as some strangely think, to Elihu. Elihu is not mentioned by the Lord and therefore in contrast to the three friends, who are explicitly rebuked by God for their erroneous teaching, we can assume that Elihu’s counsel to Job is approved by the Lord.
‘When we do not find the thing in God’s word, which we desire to know, let us understand that we need to remain ignorant of it, and keep our mouths shut, for whenever we proceed to speak about it, there will be no knowledge in us, nor anything but untruth’ (Calvin – in modern English).