If we consider the passage carefully, that is actually an astonishing statement. We take it literally first of all – its direct and obvious sense.
And in all the Proverb’s passages where the rod appears, there is some hint that we are talking about something exceptionally serious. In the punishment of children, you have got to have great care. I remember reading many, many years ago – I am sure if I am going to get this entirely correctly, it must be about 40 years ago that I read the life of Horatius Bonar, the Scottish hymn writer – and he tells of the time that he was a little boy and a mischievous boy too, son of a godly father. And he clambered over the wall to the next door’s garden and scrumped some apples. But he was seen; he was spotted, and in due course, the neighbour had firm words with his dignified father, and his father said he would see to it. So he turned to the child and he gave him a good rebuke and telling off. Well, the child went upstairs to his room and heard out of the window the neighbour remonstrating with his father and saying: You should have beaten the child. And he heard his father reply: If I had beat the boy for that, what would I do if he told me a lie?